The Allahabad High Court has ruled that a university cannot be forced to accept Joint Entrance Screening Test (JEST) scores as an alternative to the University Grants Commission National Eligibility Test (UGC NET) for doctoral admissions. A single-judge bench presided over by Justice Jaspreet Singh delivered the Verdict while dismissing a writ petition filed by a candidate challenging the admission process of Dr. Shakuntala Misra National Rehabilitation University (DSMNRU), Lucknow.
University Stand and Court Findings
The counsel who has represented DSMNRU submitted that the university’s Executive Council had officially mandated UGC NET qualification through an official decision in October 2024, which explicitly incorporated it into the 2025-26 admission prospectus. The administration has clarified that the JEST does not feature among its approved screening examinations. Upholding the University’s autonomy in laying down admission standards, the High Court has observed:-
Related Stories
- Although JEST is a reputed national-level test which is accepted by several premier research organisations, individual universities are not bound by law to accept it.
- Mandating UGC prescribed eligibility guidelines cannot be taken as arbitrary or in violation of statutory rules.
- The bench has also clarified that while higher education institutions (HEIs) have the discretion to consider JEST as a supplementary metric, courts cannot issue mandamus compelling an institution to treat it as a mandatory equivalent for the UGC NET.
Also check, HTET Biometric Verification 2025: BSEH Gives Final Opportunity for RLV Candidates, Check New Dates
UGC NET vs JEST
Prospective doctoral scholars often confuse the recognition scopes of premier national tests in physical and mathematical sciences.
|
Parameter
|
UGC/CSIR NET
|
JEST
|
|
Governing Body
|
National Testing Agency (NTA) on behalf of UGC/CSIR
|
Coordinating premier institutes like IISERs, RRI, IUCAA, etc
|
|
Appliciability
|
Recognised throughout India across Central, State, Deemed, and Private Universities
|
Primarily recognised by premier autonomous research institutes and select universities.
|
|
Institutional Obligation
|
Aligned with UGC
|
Discretionary
|
|
Score Validity
|
JRF validity is typically 2-3 years; Assistant Professor eligibility has lifetime validity.
|
Typically valid for 1 academic session for admission purposes
|
Regardless of scores earned in national competitive tests (GATE, JEST, CEED), admission eligibility is governed strictly by the criteria outlined in each specific university’s active information bulletin. Central and state universities aligning with updated UGC regulations often provide separate interview tracks for the NET-exempted candidates and university-level entrance test (RET) candidates.
Also check, Assam CM Announces Recruitment Exams for Over 5,700 Posts Across 6 Government Departments